Chaos: culturally relative? (was Re: Uroxi sense Chaos-tainted/marked ?)

From: morganconrad <morganconrad_at_...>
Date: Fri, 30 Aug 2002 03:10:44 -0000


Trying to keep it short and relevant.
  1. There definitly IS cultural relativism in defining crimes. Americans do not consider George Washington a traitor, nor do the British consider Drake a pirate. Was Orlanth a traitor? Depends on your culture. And there are borderline cases - for example, reasonable (and unreasonable :-) ) people can disagree on whether certain actions are rape or not.
  2. Comparisons of Heortling morals to RW morals are nearly meaningless. Heortlings have met their god, and religion is tightly integrated into all aspects of life. Don't go to church and you'll freeze to death in the winter, or the crops will fail. I'd tentatively suggest that most real world criminals are not particularly religious (though this will certainly stir up debate!) and confidently state that none of them have met their God.

Powered by hypermail