That should have gone to rpglist.org - don't know if it's possible
to redirect a thread anyway...
"Gianfranco Geroldi" (>>>):
>>>The idea of a Chaos Otherworld is absurd, IMO.
>>>
>>>You can't heroquest in the realm of chaos.
Henk Langeveld wrote (>):
>
>
> Correct
>
Rob wrote (>>):
>>YGWV, but I postulate the chaos otherworld is the void.
>
>
> And I agree.
>
>
>>In fact we did a heroquest in a chaos otherworld, and it was great fun!
>
>
> And I'd say that it directly contradicts your previous statement
> Heroquesting in the void to me is inconceivable - your having fun is
> probably quite right... ;-)
>
>
>>Also, if there is no chaos otherworld, where does the right clawed
>>hand come from in snakepipe hollow?
>
>
> The void is not a repository full of weird creatures trying to
> escape into the material world. The creatures are a side effect
> of the void meeting the material world. The void does not even
> create the abomination, as it can only destruct. And as it destructs
> some of the fabric of the 'real world', the 'real world' resists.
>
> Chaos creatures are 'scar tissue', born entirely from the material
> world.
>
> I fear this is indeed Glorantha-(discussion/digest) material.
>
> Cheers,
>
> Henk