Re: Six Arkats AND Re: Two Jeffs

From: John Hughes <nysalor_at_...>
Date: Fri, 4 May 2001 10:32:03 +1000

> Remember, in the old Genertela book for RQ3, they mentioned that
> "Arkat Returns -- five times" and each one is a different Arkat.
> Heck, one's a troll and one's CHAOTIC. But they are all real
> Arkats....

Careful, that's top-down roleplaying thinking and also a misreading of how prophecy works.

Even laying aside the various layers of the 'source' problem, there's no universal, omnipotent, omniscient Gloranthan Principle that declares *This is a true Arkat* or *He is the same as the original Arkat*.

Prophets read the stream of time or rightly and wrongly discern patterns in the web. Based on a shared way of perceiving and on expectations shaped by the prophecy, other folk identity likely pattern matches.

Six Arkats? Just as likely seven or eight. Or none, but every bandit from here to Sog City claiming the title. Same for the Argraths.

Death to top-down constructions! Let Glorantha *live*. :)

John

Powered by hypermail