> At 12:55 p.m. 19/04/2007, you wrote:
>> On Thu, 19 Apr 2007, Peter Metcalfe wrote:
>
>> Anyway, CoT is
>> too old to be automatically definitive
>
> If CoT is too old to be automatically definitive then surely the same
> can be said about Gods of Glorantha?
Yep, but I'm not relying on it either in this discussion.
>> and are you now saying Malia isn;t chaotic either?
>
> It's not just me saying it, it's also Cults of Terror.
Hmm, so Krarsht isn't, Malia isn't. What about Thed? Vivamort? Bagog? Are there any chaos gods?
>> While these are all old, there's a lot in the HW/HQ material that describe
>> Krarsht as chaotic.
>
> The material is mostly fan material regurgitating received lore
> without thinking
> too hard about the deliberate uncertainty in the sources.
I think we're drifting back to the core/GaG discussion. So this is my last post on this matter. My reading of this discussion is that the majority opinion here is that Krarsht is chaotic. The published material for HW/HQ says so. If the Mongoose stuff says so too, then that is what I will go by unless Greg says otherwise or until something like Thunder Rebels/Storm Tribe appears for the so called "chaos" gods in HQ and says she isn't.
Until then all krarshtkids would register on the sense chaos (Storm Tribe p.162) of Uroxi in any campaign I run.
Michael
Powered by hypermail