I found the debate on granite phalanx interesting.
Here is my opinion on the subject
When we speak of the granite phalanx regiment we
must acknowledge two facts:
1) granite phalanx is a phalanx regiment of the lunar
army.
It means three things:
- - when the soldier is accepted, he is trained as a
hoplite, ie to use a spear, to use the shieldwall
tactics, to build a camp, etc..
- - the same soldier is taught example of loyalty to
the emperor by heroic hoplites from the past
(think about it, the french foreign legion was
created in 1830, the granite phalanx is at least
1000 years old)
- - the young soldier is taught to obey the orders
shouted by his sergeant.
The soldiers don't need spells to be good hoplites. But they use the three magic of training, morale and discipline. They are magic because Glorantha is a magic world.
2) Granite Phalanx is a god and more to the point
a phalanx god, so the magic he teaches is a
phalanx magic.
Hence the spells of standfast and shieldwall.
Thus the granite phalanx hoplite who is already
a good hoplite is even better thanks to his cultic
ties.
Cheers Jean ------------------------------
Powered by hypermail