Erik:
>Uhm, according to what I read (Encyclopedia Britannica, I think)
>bronze held a BETTER edge than iron, being harder.
Nils
Hmm? I thought bronze was both softer and more brittle, the latter
since it is cast, not hammered and tempered.
Me
This talk about bronze has us metallurgists cringing. Typically, the harder a
material is, the more brittle it is. Hardness is defined as resistance to
deformation on the surface. Strength is loosely defined as resistance to a load.
Ceramics are very hard and brittle. Some types of steel are also hard and
brittle.
Bronze will be easier to grind/sharpen than steel, being softer, but it will loose its edge more quickly. Steel is more difficult to work, but will withstand more punishment.
Do not confuse hardness with strength.
Powered by hypermail