False Truths

From: MOBTOTRM_at_vaxc.cc.monash.edu.au
Date: Sat, 16 Nov 1996 16:56:54 +1100


G'day all,

False Truths

Peter and Oliver cross swords:

Oliver:
>What I am saying is this. Any belief structure can be
>based and can operate on what are falsehoods. Maybe not to the
>belief in question but to a hypothetical impartial observer-could
>you find one.

Peter:
>>But what if the belief is _unfasifiable_? Then we cannot say that
>>it is a falsehood or not. Calling such beliefs lies is making a
>>value judgement which is something that a hypothetical impartial
>>observer is by definition incapable of doing.

The most basic check point through which all scientific ideas must pass is that of falsifiability - eg. to be accepted as legitimate, a hypothesis must be capable in principle of being proved incorrect.

However, falsifiability cannot apply to a religious standpoint, eg. Oliver's assertion that all religions are wrong because gods don't exist. Take the Creationists (please!), they believe that the biblical creation narratives are divine literal truth. If they are divine literal truth they of course cannot be scientifically or historically incorrect; and any observations which conflict such views therefore must be rejected. (In contrast, scientific theories are held tentatively, and the possibility of modification or rejection of the hypothesis is always present).

Of course, in Glorantha, the distinction between science and religion is muddy, because the gods interact in meaningful way with the mortal world. Can a 'hypothetical impartial observer' - a Gloranthan hypothetical impartial observer that is, prove to the Yelmies that their religion is a fraud then? They might just be able to plant the seeds of doubt in the minds of some (just before they are consumed by the righteous cleansing flames). Fortunately, those in doubt can ask their god directly, who'll tell 'em it's all bollocks.

Oliver (Stone?):
>What I have been trying to say is that
>they're could very well be some elite or core within the faith that are
>aware of this fact. Fine, so what. Doesn't change a damn thing.

                                      ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Peter:                                     

>>It does IMO. It changes the character of the religion in that the
>>leaders *know* that their faith is a lie. Which is why I am against
>>the idea.

If Oliver means that we when you finally get to Sun Lord you're ushered into a back room at the temple and told "hey, it's a big lie but don't tell anyone, will ya", I don't buy this, not for the Yelm religion anyway. However, I'm still happy to have loopy conspiracy theorists about claiming this is so: makes for great MGF!

There might be other religions than Yelm in Glorantha where the leaders are *actively* participating in a fraud though, (eg. the Church of Immortality that Maculus of the Lunar Coders got mixed up in)...

Cheers

MOB P.S. "The Story of Sheng Seleris" - another great story from Martin Laurie! I'm looking forward to future installments...


Powered by hypermail