Monomyth - proof is in the sighs

From: Loren Miller <loren_at_wharton.upenn.edu>
Date: Mon, 3 Mar 1997 22:39:15 +0000


Martin Laurie sums up the opposing camps thusly:
> Lets look at the arguments to support both views:
> GODS ARE REAL
> GODS ARE REAL BUT CREATED
Now I personally prefer the unification church view. The gods are real, and some of their characteristics are artificial creations of humanity. For instance, let's take Orlanth. Once upon a time there was a god called Orlanth. Let's call him Orlanth Prime, just to distinguish him from the modern concept of Orlanth. Orlanth Prime was a god who did all sorts of amazing things, he pulled a bunch of dragons apart, and befriended Heler, and protected his followers from the burning sun, powered destructive storms, gave rain to the fertile powers of the earth, and many other things. If a human were ever to "see" Orlanth Prime he would see a huge, monstrous being, a whirlwind made of incomprehensibly potent energies, drawing in all sorts of things with amazing force and throwing them up into the air, crackling with lightning swords and thunderbolts, stinking of ozone, shouting through a fanged maw with a loud voice that demands worship and obeisance.

But when heroquesters run into Orlanth on the godplane they rarely see the monstrous figure of Orlanth Prime, and this is a good thing. It is much more likely they will run into the more humanistic Orlanth Humanis. Orlanth Humanis usually dresses like a hill chieftan, in clothing fashionable in the good old days when your grandparents were children. He carries a sword, and has men, women, and shadowcat companions, and wears a crown or some other symbol of chieftanship, that most likely looks a little like the Mastery rune. When he hunts or goes to war he often circles his opponent, gradually approaching them. He carries a sheaf of thunderbolts tied on his back, and they look like sparkling javelins. And in certain circumstances, when heroquesters see Orlanth, he might be taller than the usual man, or stronger, or run faster, or have sky-blue skin, or have eyes that crackle with lightning, or an impossibly loud voice, or be constantly covered by ominous thunderheads, or have great wings with blue feathers, or ride an enormous flying chariot pulled by sky-bulls, or be covered in ashes and wearing sack-cloth as he mourns for the tyrant he has slain.

There is a continuum of figures of Orlanth that may be met on the godplane, after all, and some of them are more human, some are more monstrous and incomprehensible, and many are somewhere in between. Just as there are many figures of Orlanth that may be found, so are there many stories of Orlanth, and some of the stories came from the actions of Orlanth Prime, some from Orlanth Humanis in various guises, and some came about through unknown ways. All we know is that Orlanth Prime is NOT responsible for all the myths that bear its name and carry heroquesters on a path to its power, and that is the real meaning when people say that the gods have lost their free will. Their stories are no longer their own, but the stories of mortal men.

Cheers,
Loren

+++++++++++++++++++++++23

Loren Miller <loren_at_wharton.upenn.edu> A priest, a rabbi, a Penn student, and an elephant walk into a bar. The bartender says, "what is this, some kinda joke?"

Powered by hypermail