IIRC Greg pretty much concurred with that position at the heroquest talk at RQConDU
My thoughts are pretty much in complete agreement with what Alex says as regards gifts and geases, and I think its a common pattern for heroquesting, though with the more powerful gifts the geases become magical prohibitions instead, a geas of male celibacy becoming impotency. Its also worth noting that 'heroic' level passions and traits are a manifestation of the same thing, IMO - having a zero lustful, or indeed a chaste above 20/100% is very similar.
A long rambling document about heroquesting and strange new directions RQ magic could go is on my website at http://www.cwr.uwa.edu.au/~cake/magicrules.html, some thoughts on 'Will' in the paragraph headed 'other important otherworld things'. I was originally intending to actually turn some of this into real rules someday, but I think I'll wait and find out more about what the future holds. Lets hope some of this thinking makes it into GTG
Cheers
David
Powered by hypermail