Lord's questions

From: Peter Metcalfe <metcalph_at_voyager.co.nz>
Date: Wed, 6 May 1998 12:09:02 +1200 (NZST)


Julian Lord:

>If the Scientist were *actually* a scientist, and not a rhetorical
>figment, surely he would be in ignorance until the phenomenon
>*actually occurred* ?

>Scientists, IMHO, _observe_ rather than predict?

What definition of science are you using? No RW scientist follows these precepts.

>A Gloranthan scientist (Lhankor Mhy, anyone?) might even discover
>tangible _evidence_ of the physical _existence_ of Orlanth.

Yes. He would say it was a wind. He might observe magical evidence of Orlanth in which case he would say it was a wind spirit.

>I suppose that orthodox westerners have immortality, and orthodox theists
>have Resurrection, and orthodox primitives have shamans who keep it all to
>themselves, and fairness be hanged ...

Immortality spells are anathema in the West.

Powered by hypermail