Re: slightly off-topic tidbit

From: TTrotsky_at_aol.com
Date: Mon, 4 Jan 1999 16:44:19 EST


Loren Miller:

<< The Anasazi are revered not only as ancestors of the Hopi and other Pueblo Indians, but also for their astonishing advances in engineering, astronomy, art, and architecture. Many New Age adherents believe the Anasazi even had a superior civilization based on pacifism, consensus government, classless society, and refined spirituality. >>

       On a related note, Frauds Myths & Mysteries in Archeology (Kenneth Feder, 1996) has this to say on the Anasazi:

        'Some Native Americans are uncomfortable with the prospect of a
        group of mostly white, middle-class people romanticising and
        appropriating indigenous religious beliefs and native cultural images
        for their own cosmic salvation... For example, Rick Romancito, a
        Taos and Zuni Indian, is unhappy about the New Age fascination 
        with all things Indian. He decries their melding of different beliefs
        taken from different tribes into an all-inclusive "Indian religion"
that
        never existed among actual Indians... Romancito is especially 
        angry at the cloying New Age assumption that Indians are
        "repositories of 'indigenous spiritual knowledge'", gurus one and
        all just ripe for the intellectual picking. He tars such a stereotype
        of Indians as spiritual mystics with the same brush he does for
        more obviously negative popular images such as "the drunken
        Indian" or the noble but defeated savage.'

       However, in a rather pathetic attempt to bring this back at least
partially on-topic, I'd add the same isn't necessarily true in Glorantha. While its clear that no third age cultures are utopias endowed with great spiritual understanding (despite what some Lunars/Kralori/etc. might try to tell you) there's no reason that that can't have been so back in the Golden Age. Indeed then, a high proportion of cultures probably were utopias; that reflects a common RW myth about our distant ancestors, along with Atlanteans and the like, and myth is real in Glorantha. Of course the utopias were pretty different one from another, and would not have recognised each other as such - Hsunchen and Dara Happans just wouldn't have seen eye to eye for example.

      Harmony, and even spiritual understanding are in the eye of the beholder...

Forward the glorious Red Army!

     Trotsky


Powered by hypermail