Usually No*.
> It would seem odd for the initiates of Elmal/Redalda not to have
> horsemanship and tend horses skills, for example, since Beren the
> rider initiates do get those skills, and Redalda initiates are if
> anything even more involved in horses. On the other hand, both
> Redalda and Rigsdal have substantial skill lists, and virtues, and
> players claiming all of those plus the skills and virtues of their
> greater god seems, well, almost munchkinish.
It's a question of what the worshipper wants, really - Elmal/Redalda is specifically noted as how *women* get to worship Elmal (normally a male-only cult). So Elmal/Redalda is mostly for Warrior Women who want the Combat and Light affinities of Elmal (and his skills) with the horse magics of Redalda. This is a person who leans more towards the combat side than the nurturing/animal husbandry side (and you'll note that many of the Redalda skills are duplicated by feats in the Bless Horses affinity).
Someone who wants to be the Horse Doctor/Breeder type should choose Redalda alone - no combat skills, but pleanty of healing/nurturing.
*As always, a player can add abilities in his 100 words, so make him spend the 6 words to say "He knows the skills of Redalda" and bingo, he can have them!
RR
Powered by hypermail