Re: Cancelling Materies with multiple opponents

From: Antonio Álvarez del Cuvillo <antalvarez1976_at_...>
Date: Tue, 19 Aug 2003 15:59:27 -0000

> So Harald makes a single roll, but his skill differs : he's at 19
>against V1 and V2 and 19W against V3. Lets assume he rolls a nine,
>and all the villains roll a 7. Against V1 that's a success v. a
>success, but V1 rolled lower. Marginal Victory for V1. Against V2
>that's a success vs. a fail. Minor Victory for Harold. Against V3
>that's a *critical* (bumped up by the mastery) vs. a success.
>Another minor victory for Harold.

So, the final result is marginal victory for the V's (the best result for the opponents). It has more sense, but it's a bit strange for me.

> Now, I wouldn't allow this at all. I'd rule that Harold loses his
>6 points (leaving him at 19W). V1 as the highest number would make
>the roll, but augmented by V2 and V3, for a total of +5. So that
>would be 19 vs 15.

That's a good idea.

> I would make each attack a seperate roll (5W vs. 10, 2W vs. 5, 19W
>vs. 19).

with separate action points biddings isn't it?

Regards,

Antonio