Uh, Peter, check back. I've never argued that he could use his abilities outside of Pavis as magic. I agree with you. My point was that, given that this is how the setting is that we should come up with other ways to make the character valid. I don't have a problem with the idea of altering canon either, just that your view is just as valid. In any case, it all misses the point.
> >So, yeah, sure, for the average Pavisite devotee, they wouldn't go. But a
> >PC, sure, why not?
>
>Don't misrepresent the debate. The argument was about why shouldn't his
>magic work outside Pavis and the related statement that having Pavis
>magic restricted to the locality of Pavis is far too restricting.
See, here's the problem, Peter. The history of the thread is:
http://games.groups.yahoo.com/group/HeroQuest-rules/message/18822 In this thread, Flynnkd2 asks: "I was just wondering how others might handle this, or do the HQ rules actually say something about it anyplace?"
"This" in this case refering to the problem of Pavis city magic seeming too restrictive to allow a player to participate abroad.
Your response was that no such character should be allowed because cannon made it so that they couldn't use their magic outside of the city. Responding to the idea that perhaps bending the restriction would be a way out of the problem.
Then a separate debate started up about whether or not such could be reasonably rationalized, or whether or not YGMV is viable here...all not at all pertinent to the original question. Flynnkd wasn't looking for reasons how not to allow this, but how to allow it. How to make it work. If your response is that you can't without altering canon, or having some other reason to go, consider your point made. That still leaves a lot of options, however.
That's not to say that the other debate isn't on a valid subject. If you want to continue, by all means, I don't care. But my point is that little about this has helped the original poster. The secondary debate has derailed any progress that was being made on the original topic.
Mike
Powered by hypermail