Maybe I'm some sort of bad wrong thinker, but I'm not convinced that these two alternatives are completely mutually exclusive. Including some real world yardsticks in no way prevents anyone from setting their Resistances according to dramatic need instead.
Personally, I'd favour including advice on both alternatives as they're both valid approaches. I've certain used both of them at different times, going with whichever strikes me as most appropriate for the situation at hand.
> 2: Does the rating 'measure' the ability
> Again there are two schools of thought
There does seem to be another variable being discussed here, independently of whether you put a ceiling on the rating for 'mundane' abilities. It's the suggestion that 'similar' abilities with different narrative qualities/names ought to be treated differently. Following this argument, Superhuman Strength 17 would automatically beat Strongest Man In Town 10W2.
On the other hand, some people feel that it's simpler to, if an ability is supposed to be so powerful, give it a higher rating. After all, that's what Masteries are for.
Regards,
Bruce
Powered by hypermail