Re: Re: How do you compare published abilities without numbers?

From: Ashley Munday <aescleal_at_...>
Date: Tue, 24 Feb 2009 20:59:37 +0000 (GMT)


Hi Chris,

While I hate to drag the discussion of down the depths of British porn, if you've read "Lady Chatterley's Lover" who out of her Mellors and the title character's husband:

More to the point, how do we know which ones were the exemplars in the fields of inheriting cash and being willy wavers of the highest order? The text tells us, we don't need character sheets for them.

The point here is that with text you can convey enough of a sense of what is normal that even begininning narrators/GMs should have a fair stab at being able to set resistences/narrate the results of conflicts between NPCs without too much effort.

Anyway, I look forward to the Sartar Book by D.H. Lawrence Whitaker... Especially the scene between Kallyr and the Broyan with lots of naughty words.

Cheers,

Ash

Chris Lemens <chrislemens_at_...> wrote:

> From: Chris Lemens <chrislemens_at_...>
> Subject: Re: How do you compare published abilities without numbers?
> To: HeroQuest-rules_at_yahoogroups.com
> Date: Monday, 23 February, 2009, 11:42 PM
> Ian replies cogently to me:
>
> > > Nope, that doesn't do it. It works fine if
> the players have picked a
> > > side with respect to the NPC -- either helping or
> hindering. But when
> > > faced with the choice, the players need the
> information that their
> > > characters ought to know. The numbers gave the
> narrator at least
> > > some guidance.
> >
> > Channelling Greg - Gloranthans don't know the
> numbers!
>
> No, but they do know that Oddi's going to win a debate
> against Braggi and Braggi would absolutely slaughter Oddi in
> combat. That's the kind of knowledge that numbers _can_
> convey quickly. (I realize that there are all sorts of other
> things that aren't going to be covered, so there's a
> limitation there.)
>
> > Seriously if you wanted to pick someone to side with
> in a political
> > debate at work you would base it on who you agreed
> with more, what
> > your experience was of working with them, what
> successes and failures
> > they had. You would have no idea that one was 10W the
> other 17W. So
> > you would pick based on what others told you.
>
> Sure, and numbers convey that well. If Oddi's got a
> mastery on Braggi in public speaking, everyone in the clan
> will know it.
>
> > If it ever came to competition between the two then
> you risk
> > de-protagonising the players by worrying about the
> leaders numbers.
> > Either it is about the players actions and the outcome
> reflects that,
> > or you narrate the outcome depending on what the story
> needs.
>
> So, take my hypothetical, please:
> 1.    You're new to Glorantha. (That's the
> point, right?)
> 2.    You are narrating out of a published supplement.
> 3.    The supplement presents a bunch of narrator
> characters.
> 4.    Through play, the community in the supplement
> comes into a conflict where each side has a champion.
> Let's assume it is a lawmoot.
> 5.    The supplement describes each champion as
> having an ability applicable to an upcoming contest.
> Let's assume that one has "orator" and the
> other has "rabble-rouser."
> 6.    The players want to be with the winner. (Or,
> alternatively, need to figure out whether they need to find
> a back door and a quick escape route.)
>
> How would you let the players assess who the winner is
> going to be? Channelling Ian, here is my guess at
> approximately what your answer will be: First, if this
> conflict is important to the story, the player characters
> should have a central role in it. So, they should decide on
> some basis other than being on the side of the winner.
> <At which point I smack you with a weighty law-school
> tome for not answering the professor within the bounds
> of the hypothetical. But you then go on.> Ouch! Well, if
> that's not the case, then most likely, the orator and
> the rabble-rouser should be at more or less the same level,
> so that the characters can influence the outcome and gain a
> new tie to two narrator characters, one of whom might be
> indebted to them and the other of whom might nurse a grudge.
> Second, if the whole event is important enough, you can play
> out the process of discovering the information about the two
> contenders. The players have to go around asking
> about their reputations, their past debates, and so on.
> Those mini-contests might produce truth, lies, or something
> in between. On the flip side, if the conflict really
> isn't important, then just make up any old thing. Or if
> it's just a mechanism to run the players out of town,
> then let the players discover the opposite of the trust
> about the contenders. In any case, the system encourages you
> to be creative and go with the story.
>
> Back to speaking with my own voice, I think that most
> new-to-Glorantha narrators would be frustrated at not being
> able to figure that out from the book. Maybe learning
> "make it up" is just part of the learning curve.
>
> > I'll let you into a secret. I produced a lot of
> numbers for Red Cow. I
> > even had a sim system for them (use the saga rules in
> HQ1). In every
> > contest I just ended up basing the numbers off what
> the players told
> > me thier numbers were so that I could give them an
> appropriate
> > challenge. I never had two npcs go toe-to-toe for any
> reason. If two
> > narrator characters argued and the players could not
> affect the
> > outcome then I just summarized.
> > So I'm speaking as someone who went down this
> route and
> > realised it was a waste of effort.
>
> Look, I don't disagree. I think I played in one of your
> Red Cow scenarios a couple of Tentacles ago -- it was an
> Orlanthi wedding contest. I enjoyed it greatly. I've
> also been down the road of trying to assign numbers to lots
> of NPC's and hated every moment of it so much that I
> gave up and left blanks that I said to myself I would fill
> in later. (They are still blank; now they will remain
> so.) But that doesn't mean I don't recognize that
> many do find some value in the numbers. I think I've
> identified a significant part of that value and it's
> particular valuable to people new to Glorantha. I'm
> trying to figure out how to work around the problem, not
> change the system.
>
> Chris Lemens
>
>
> ------------------------------------
>
> To Post a message, send it to:
> HeroQuest-rules_at_...
> To Unsubscribe, send a blank message to:
> HeroQuest-rules-unsubscribe_at_...m
>
> For assistance, contact the list ownerYahoo! Groups Links
>
>
>

Powered by hypermail