Re: [HeroQuest-Rules] Augments and arithmetic are irritating...

From: David Dunham <david_at_...>
Date: Sat, 20 Oct 2012 10:21:03 -0400


Ashley Munday
>> Because it makes narrative sense. Winning Smile is not always enough to charm the ladies, sometimes you want to ensure success by applying something from that Collection of Exotic Perfumes, or use a relationship with her guild to learn what her favorite color is. In game terms, one main ability, helped by another.

>
> How does "Collection of Exotic Perfumes 2W" as an ability make more narrative sense than "Used Collection of Exotic Perfumes to woo the ladies" +6. Confused of Portland here. In both cases you have to roll something - the narration (which is probably identical for generating the bonus) and mechanics (one die roll for both) are going to be almost the same. And the point is the lingering benefit lingers so once you've worked out how to stench out one group's resistance others will fall before you far easier. Wafting the Lynx around is something that doesn't vary much between contests at least judging by my experience of people I used to work with, although that was more a lingering penalty.

My intent was that Winning Smile was your main ability in all cases, but sometimes it was not sufficient by itself and so had to be augmented.

And if you had chosen to woo this lady by no only your winning smile but also doing a little asking around in her guild, that is not something that would have lingering consequences on other guild relations. It is very specific to this contest.

The narrative part was that using a combination of abilities makes sense, instead of just one (but relying on things that happened earlier).

Again, my personal preference is that helping skills not require a roll, just add the +3. Pick one, add it. Simple to do, and it seemed consistent with a narrative game.

Gavain Sweetman

> Actually, what I meant here was that I precalculated the automodification value for each skill. So the Character sheet would have entries like this:
>
> Acute Senses 7W(+5)

Ah, just doing the division ahead of time. That's at least relevant.

David Dunham
Glorantha/HQ/RQ page: www.pensee.com/dunham/glorantha.html

Powered by hypermail