Re: style

From: Thomas Bagwell <tnbagwell_at_...>
Date: Tue, 11 Jul 2000 16:18:09 -0000

> > > the mechanics of a RPG, of whatever kind, should
> > > represent the reality they are modeling, otherwise they are
> > > useless.
> >
> > I think the HW mechanics do just that, however the reality they
> > are modeling may not be the one that you are familair with!
>
> The Hero Wars mechanics don't model reality at all. They model
> drama. In other words, they don't model the *process* of
> determining an outcome so much as they simply determine the results.

Well...they model 'dramatic reality' fairly well, if you don't mind the phrase.

The primary consideration for me as a GM when it comes to any set of rules is consistency. I want the outcome to be in line with the outcome that occurred in other similar situations. In a more specific sense, I want them to be able to produce results that fit in with my expectation of the world and setting, and to do so consistently.

"Good" runners (as opposed to truly exceptional runners) being able to outrun a horse bugs me. I'm now no longer certain of the intent behind the world and setting, and now I don't know what to expect. Thus, I don't know if there is consistency or not. Heroic characters might be able to outrun a horse with great effort...or defeat a bear without weapons...etc. But I didn't expect those levels of ability to fall within the 1w to 10w range. Maybe above 1w2. Horses that only run at 2w weren't what I was expecting...

Sorry to ramble. I've been reading the posts for some time now, but haven't posted often. I'm combining a couple of threads here, I think...

Tom Bagwell