I am curious about Wulf's suggestion that the "Winter" has a 14
resistance against my winter countermagic.
It seems to be a correct interpretation of the rules, but it just
seems wrong to me.
Surely there is a difference between a mild winter (3W1) and deep
winter (5W4) -- and that it is harder to resist the deep winter than
the mild winter.
Doesn't the size of the object resisted have some effect on magical
enchantments? By extension, shouldn't a huge phenomenon such as WINTER
have a large resistance as well?
>
> > Who said the objective of the 5W4 winter was to kill anyone. The
> objective of
> > the cold winter is to make someone chilly. It almost always
suceeds
> and no
> > one in Dragon Pass claims it is "too warm" during the winter.
>
> I like this... winter has a 5W4 chance of 'being winter'... it
> doesn't actually DO anything, it just IS winter... Solar cultists
> will have to work damn hard to make it summer in Dark Season.
>
> Wulf