Re: Shields

From: bethexton_at_...
Date: Tue, 07 Sep 2004 02:47:52 -0000

I can think of three explanations:

  1. Diplomacy. They have things the other tribes want, so even if they raid and skirmish with the bison riders, nobody tries to actually kill off too many of them. Maybe they can deal with a specific foe better, maybe they have a ritual importance. Maybe they make the best drinks when people get together at the Paps.
  2. They actually do have missile weapons. There are all sorts of ways you can explain this. Easiest is that they have only a small number of such, who do most of the skirmishing. A variant is that they have some magic to substitute for missile weapons, but this isn't shown in the rules either. There are other explanations.....but I don't like this option much myself.
  3. There are of course exceptions to every rule. The Bison Riders do fine in Prax, so they are obviously an exception :) I'd call it largely an armor thing. Each tribe uses the hides of its brothers/animals. Bison hide is heavier than that provided by the other tribes, and bison themselves have a reasonable amount of protection, especially from the front. Most missile weapons in the waste have points of fire hardened wood or flint. These can cut the hide, but only on a fairly solid hit, so are far less effective against bison riders than others. Also the bison are strong enough for the riders to wear armor and carry big solid shields. Finally, the bison don't tire easily, and can carry a charge for a fair while. SO, what happens is that the lighter tribes can often shoot off a fair number of bison riders, but in the right circumstances the bison riders can charge through the missiles and eventually run down the lighter beasts, where they are totally dominant. So it comes down to strategic moving and how much you are willing to chance their charge, which keeps the other tribes from just whittling them away.

--Bryan

Powered by hypermail