Re: Last Samurai

From: illuminate33 <inarsus-ferilt-z_at_LPVb2oZ4PH4zog_v27jz61mPwt3QlZRqdD8uBudMXjSYryRCMrEUIviOUtY>
Date: Sat, 07 Feb 2004 09:44:08 -0000


> > Naah, real bushido died in the 18th, not 19th century.
"No, it died out with the beginning of Tokugawa Shogunate."
"No, it died out with the start of Warring States period."
"It has existed in only our virtuous hearts..." etc.. 

>
> I can't claim any knowledge of "the real" bushido (can anyone?
> especially the one that was practiced as opposed to written
down?),

As european chivalry, I can roughly divide into three categories, "real" Bushido, Bushido "in Legend and Folklore", or "Bushido" in texts (like that of Hagakure).

> but even a casual scan of a few texts like Hagakure show something
> with way too much emphasis on "obey your lord" and very little
about,
> say, thinking about what is right or rescuing damsels in distress,
or
> for that matter helping starving peasants. One suspects that it
and a
> lot of other political "thought" was manufactured specifically to
> keep the Tokugawa regime in power.

I agree, it sounds similar to me having only Castiglione's "Courtier" as European Chivalrous canon. I think when text appear, original idea get bored and already dying.

<<Castiglione, Baldassare, Conte Italian author, courtier, and politician; wrote "Il Cortegiano" 1528 (also "The Courtier", "Il Libro d'Oro") _1478-1529>>

TI            

Powered by hypermail