RE: Re: Melisande, Narib, et al.

From: Peter Metcalfe <metcalph_at_...>
Date: Thu, 11 Mar 2004 16:34:19 +1300


Jeff

>Me > In an commentary on this in the glorantha digest (about whether
> > the Orlanthi had become Hsunchen), Greg said that the Hidden
> > Kings had taken wolf form and started devouring other Orlanthi
> > such as Heort's deer people. I had suggested that the Hidden
> > Kings might have also turned into ravens whereupon Greg suggested
> > a Dove Tribe.

>I think a lot of this was superceded by the Dawn Age discussion that
>Greg, Harold Smith, Stephen Martin, Shannon Appelcline, Rob Heinsoo and
>I had.

No, it came much later. March 9th 2001.

         DD>>I think this episode is code for folks reverting to hsunchenism.

         Me>I think it more plausible that the Hidden King had obtained
         >a magical shirt that allowed him to transform into a Raven,

         It could be.

         But as noted, not all animal shapechanging is hsunchen. As "Vadrus
         and the Logic Tribe" shows, the Orlanthi know that some animals are
         god-originated,  not just hsunchen.

         >Wolf or somesuch so he could eat foods that no human could.
         >Eventually the corpses ran out and he began preying on his
         >own people. This has the advantage in that it rings true
         >to the Orlanthi tradition while turning Hsunchen does not.

         This is very close to what I know of it.
         I know I was inspired to this by the Sigurd and Sinfjoti story 
where they
         become wolves.
         And the animosity of the last Vingkotlings (wolves) with the first
         Heortlings, who were deer(-like), is not an accident.
         Ravens too eh! That makes them even a bit worse. Perhaps Heort was 
aided
         byt he red breasted swans too.

                 Glorantha Digest #8 v353.

>We discussed Heort and the survival of the
>Vingkotling-Heortlings to very great detail. The Orlanthi never became
>Hsunchen.

Which is what I was saying in the original debate.

>Heort ultimately had to defeat the Hidden Kings

Which is what I was saying, no?

--Peter Metcalfe

Powered by hypermail