RE: Accents (was [HeroQuest-RPG] Re: literacy)

From: Jane Williams <janewilliams20_at_...>
Date: Thu, 23 Sep 2004 22:07:38 +0100


> FWIW, I don't think Heortlander *sounds* anything like
> English.

Of course not. But we have to represent it by English when we're dealing predominantly with Heortling characters. The "standard" language of the fictional world gets represented by the standard language of the real world: whatever either of those are for a certain set of circumstances.

Which, trying hard to be unbiased, possibly means that the English equivalent in Glorantha is actually New Pelorian?

> We know it has lots of *r*, *l*, *n(d)(th)*, *th*,
> and *kt* sounds.

From names, presumably?

> Probably lots of rolling "l"s and "r"s.
> Lots of stops, fricative, and liquid consonents.

But where do you get this from?

> More to the point, as a West Coast American, none of those
> accents do it for me. Yorkshire, Lancashire or other
> Northern English dialects mean very little to me, other than
> they are pretty much unintelligible and inexplicable.

And most Southern Brits would agree with you. Though Glaswegian is considerably worse. (Nick's right, though. They're accents, not dialects, as I understand the distinction. Same vocab and grammar, mostly, just different pronounciation.)

Powered by hypermail