Re: Re: Supplies, questions raised IMOG

From: Joerg Baumgartner <joe_at_...>
Date: Thu, 21 Oct 2004 12:30:04 +0200 (CEST)


Simon Miller
>

> Volterra is also a rocky outcrop; it is very steep sided (it took about 15
> minutes to drive up the windy road to the top). I'm not a geologist but
> I'd guess that a lot of organic material would accumulate on the top of a
> flat-topped rock over time, as with Jane's pic of the block; grass and
> shrubs would be the natural state of vegetation.

Not necessarily, and probably a lot less than you expect where there is wind erosion. My favourite comparison are the Aran Islands in the Galway Bay, west of Ireland. Even though the rock is laminated vertically, there are lots of places where the wind takes away good soil even from the crevices. Pictures of Dun Angus ought to be at Google...

> My thinking is that a tribe that highly values cattle, would want it's
> place of refuge in a crisis to be able to support the cattle for a
> moderate period of time; I guess the Iron Age hill forts in the UK, with
> their large grassy enclosures, may have performed such a function.

True in both cases. However, Whitewall wasn't designed as a hillfort, but as an exercise in impregnability.

> Presumably the grazing would only last weeks or months and the cattle
> would be eaten early on in the siege; then later any horses.

Actually, the cattle could be fed on thatching and straw bedding for some time, hopefully providing dairy products until slaughtered.

Powered by hypermail