RE: Re: Drawing of whitewall...

From: donald_at_...
Date: Fri, 27 May 2005 15:21:42 GMT


In message <20050527072750.PQIK10462.aamta02-winn.mailhost.ntl.com_at_homemaster> "Jane Williams" writes:
>> The links I've send on the precedent message didn't work.
>
>I think you used the Yahoo temporary URL, not the "real" one. They always
>time out after an hour or so. And they're a mile long, and unreadable.
>
>> I resend the file to the group...
>
>Is it any different from the last version? Still *very* impressive.
>
>That makes it a lot clearer what's what, and where, in fact. And makes me
>wonder about the factual accuracy of some of Mitch's ideas.
>
>How do you get your wagons up to Tarkalor's Gate? Once on that viaduct
>affair, yes, fine (assuming you don't get blown off), but how do you get up
>that steep bit of rock in the first place?

The map we've been using shows a long hill at the other end of the viaduct rather than a peak.

>How come the gate has been swapping sides as often as we once suggested?
>It's incredibly well-protected. I'd seen the main gatehouse as being at
>"ground" level, almost, so you could have waves of troops hitting the walls
>around it. You'd need scaling ladders and so on, sure, but as it is the
>place just isn't attackable other than by flyers.

From previous sketches I'd thought there was a reasonably flat area around the gate. Access to that area being difficult except over the viaduct.

>In fact, why not destroy that viaduct, so as to stop any attacks at
>all? I'm sure it isn't being used as a supply route during the siege.

Anything that impressive is going to be tied into the city magic. The defenders could destroy it but don't know the consequences - it might destroy the whole gatehouse.

>Take the entire picture and divide the height by about four?

I seem to remember a similar comment when the sketch was originally done. The main city walls are very high - minimum of 120 ft.

>Thanks, Sam. I'd never have realised how far this differed from the stories
>we've been putting there without being able to see it so clearly. See it?
>With that picture, I can almost smell it!

-- 
Donald Oddy
http://www.grove.demon.co.uk/

Powered by hypermail