Re: My Glorantha%

From: Richard Hayes <richard_hayes29_at_DnajhzU9fzYCf9yPab6vcUSbvxn_kl5o2MSeXUV5nJTMV-8d6ZmV7xUJ61Jw>
Date: Sun, 24 Jun 2012 20:28:25 +0100 (BST)

I meant simply that the fixed castes of Alphas and Epsilons and all those in-between in Brave New Worldare much more like the fixed caste system of the Rokari than  the social mobility of the Hrestoli in Loskalm. That in some way Fordism is a bit like Rokarism with science. Rokarism itself is not very into science other than by treading well-work paths across the Essence Plane.

I didn't for one moment suggest that Rokari Malkionism was high-tech. By the Third Age no-one in Glorantha is technologically-oriented except for the Mostali (and Leonardo). It was a bit different when the God-learners were around -- but much good did it do them. Indeed for this very reason the Rokari are probably even more wary of technology than most.

Richard Hayes

To: Sent: Sunday, 24 June 2012, 19:12
Subject: Re: My Glorantha%  

Surely Brave New World is the opposite of Loskalm
/// The opposite, or the other side of the coin ?

its Alphas and Epsilons are much more like high-tech Rokarism, or maybe even the Mostali? 
/// Rokari isn't about "high tech" - they don't do novelties, technical or otherwise. Alphas are talari and epsilons are zzaburi, both concerned with the well-being of society, each in their role, as the Book ordained.

Though to me the Mostali differ from the Malkioni in that their caste system is not (as?) pyramidal. Officially they consider their eight or nine castes to be "separate but equal", even though some castes exist to teach or manage the others. Hell, maybe the Mostali even have enough of a hive mind for this to be largely true? Or do the Mostali have more of a 1984 edge to them -- in which some privileged castes (or groupings within those castes?), are "party members" rather than "proles"?
/// Being inhuman, the mostali are not IMO subject to such concepts. They are built to fulfill specific tasks, and their programming includes co-operation with other castes as necessary to their task. This programming leaves out anything not work-related, which is why they developp their obssesive "hobbies" with the fervor of an autist. That's also why their malfunction rate (read : heresies) is so high : this programming is too light, too small to fill their minds - so they err. Even Mostal makes mistakes. Or does it?

Yahoo! Groups Links

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]            

Powered by hypermail