Definitely agree. If all magic weapons are just +1/+2 etc what is the point in having any form of description other than a name. In fact I would probably limit something like a slaying sword to being real cool against the named foe and just a normal sword against anything else. But yes such items are rare and you just can't or at least shouldn't be able to buy them, no matter how good the justification.
Proliferation sounds like God Learner mass production to me.
Jarec
Powered by hypermail