Re: Caste Mobility

From: Nick Brooke <Nick_Brooke_at_compuserve.com>
Date: Mon, 3 Nov 1997 03:33:29 -0500



Here's an edifying little story from the Persian "Shah-Nama", the Epic of the Kings. Bahram is a pretty good Shah...

"At early dawn one day Bahram went out hunting on the plain accompanied
 by his retinue. On his right was his minister Hormaz and on his left his keen-witted priest. They told him stories, speaking much of Jamshid and Faridun. Ahead of them ran hounds and panthers and over the plain king-falcons and hawks were being sent up all day long, yet when the blazing sun had reached the zenith not a trace of wild ass or gazelle had been seen. Wearied by the fiercely blazing sun, the king despondently turned back from the hunting ground.

"There came into view ahead of them a verdant hamlet full of houses,
men and animals, and out of it on to the road there emerged a numerous  crowd to view the spectacle of the cavalcade. The monarch himself was in ill-humour, being heated and desirous to rest himself in the place. But no one there saluted him. It was as though the earth had petrified those asses, until the king became enraged at the stupidity of the people there, and he cast no kindly glance upon them. To his priest the Shah said,

"'Let this ill-starred place become the resort of wild beasts and may
the water in its stream turn to pitch.'

"The priest understood what the king's words implied and turning away
from the road he addressed the inhabitants, to whom he said,

"'This flourishing town, full of fruits and men and animals, has
greatly pleased Shah Bahram, and he desires to establish a new order here. Every one of you is promoted to be an elder so that this fine village may be turned into a city. In this place even women and children are now elders, needing to obey no one's command; here no one is a hireling and no one master, but all walk the same path. Women, men and children -- all are elevated to the headship; each single one is chieftain of the town.'

"A great shout arose in that rich town out of joy now that all
equally were elders. Women and men, servants and hirelings thereafter  declared their opinions as heads of the town, and since the youths of the place had lost their awe of the elders they at once cut off their heads. Every man attacked his fellow and blood flowed in every direction. The inhabitants felt that Resurrection Day had arrived in that rural spot and took flight from it. Only a few ancients were left, helpless and crippled; for now all means of cultivation, work and carriage had vanished. The aspect of the whole town declined into one of desolation, the trees having withered because there was no water in the stream. The plain became a desert and the houses fell into ruin, now that all the people and animals had fled away.

"A year passed and springtime arrived. Again the Shah went hunting
in that direction and came to that place which had once been flourishing  and happy. Now when he looked he saw it no longer existed in its old form; the trees were withered and the houses in ruins, in the whole region there was neither man nor beast. The king's cheeks paled at the sight; he felt the fear of God and was tormented by sorrow. He said to the priest,

"'How sad that so pleasant a village should have become a desert.
Quickly set about restoring it; spend money so that they shall no further suffer misery.'

"The counsellor left the king's presence and swiftly moved about
the desolate place, hastening from one empty house to another. At last he came upon an old man sitting idle. He dismounted from his horse, greeted him, made room for him by his side and said,

"'My elderly master, who destroyed this once flourishing place?'

"The man replied,

"'One day our sovereign passed through this district of ours and
a foolish priest came with him, one of those great ones whose deeds bear no fruit. He told us that we were all nobles and that we were not to pay reverence to anyone; we were all headmen in the town, even women and men were all superior to the elders. As soon as he said it the whole of the town was in turmoil, filled with looting and killing and beating. May God requite him in due measure ! May grief and pain and hardship ever renew themselves upon him! The affairs of this place go from bad to worse; we are an object over which to shed tears.'

"At the old man's story the priest was grieved. He asked who the
village headman was and was asked in reply who could be headman in a place where grass-seed was the only fruit. The good man said to him,

"'You be the elder. In every task you are to be the diadem on the
head. Demand money from the monarch's treasury as well as seed and oxen and asses and food. Drag anyone you find idle into the town; all are subject to you and you are the chief. Call no curses down on that priest; it was not of his own desire that he uttered those words. If you require aid from the royal treasures I will send it to you. Demand as much as you need...'"

        [The newly-appointed headman rejoiced and by the following
        spring the village was enjoying greater prosperity than it
        had before. The moral of the story is then given to the
        king; namely, that when two conflicting ideas come into a
        man's mind or when a town has two chiefs, confusion and
        ruin are the result.]

                *       *       *

Now, it seems to me likely that Malkioni lands with a rigid caste system will tell stories much like this, showing how any degree of caste mobility is a harsh infliction upon the people, designed to lead them into dissension, penury, internal strife and failure. Only the God-given system of immobile, inflexible castes is in the long term found to be sustainable. (After all, are not the Hrestoli Idealists of Loskalm even now being assailed by the Kingdom of War, self-evidently a Scourge of God, to punish them for their impious notions?)

::::
Nick
::::


Powered by hypermail