MOB:
> You're wrong because the previous version is obviously far more > interesting, and your concept is plainly naff. But it's pointless trying to > convince you, because Greg has done a 180 degree turn and now says there > "is, was and only ever will be one Moonson" and that appears to be that. > If I did change your mind, you'd still have to toe the party line and would > then end up having to write things you disagree with:
Martin:
>>Now, I've stated clearly that I don't want to get involved with books that
>>piss in other peoples pools, so I won't, but you can hardly expect me to
>>write things I disagree with and have disagreed with since day one of reading
>>them or seeing them?
MOB, I think the crux of the matter is the love/hate relationship that we have with Greg's creation and, for some of us at least, with the shaman-arkati-trickster himself.
But this is Glorantha we're talking about, *Greg Stafford's Glorantha*. Not Gary Gygax & Dave Arneson's World of Greyhawk, nor M. A. R. Barker's Tekumel (I forgot an accent somewhere, didn't I?!!), nor J.R.R. Tolkien's Middle-Earth...
Reading KoS, for instance, made me at the same time grateful & angry toward Greg. And I hadn't even understood the whole Yelmalio business on my first reading!!! When I got it at last, I became positively furious...
But looking back at it now, I am very impressed with what Greg managed to do with this delighfully clumsy little book, to take just this example. You & Nick & Jane & many others greatly increased our knowledge & understanding of our beloved sunny survivor *after* the publication of KoS. And all this because of our favorite chaolifornian, the one & only Greg Stafford who wrote those too few & infuriating paragraphs on YO & Elmal.
Because, let's face it: one day there will be a Glorantha without its creator & this day we shall all be the poorer for it! (If we make it 'til then!)
Besides, just like you said, it's Greg you have to convince & not Martin & Wesley whom we should thank for all the insider scoop they let go on the list. I suspect, by the way, that with your previous experience you find it easier to argue with the Incredible Martin Laurie -proxy and/or would be usurpator that he is- than with Greg "Red Emperor" Stafford himself!?! ;)
To conclude:
I go to sleep now. Good night MOB! Good night everybody!
Christoph Kohring
P.S.: I'm eagerly waiting for She Guards Us because I'm a big fan of Onslaught as well as of the Gwandor Saga...
Powered by hypermail