Elf Campaigns

From: Lemens, Chris <CLemens_at_exchange.webmd.net>
Date: Thu, 24 Aug 2000 14:16:19 -0400

Alex, cogently:
>An elf campaign would be in essence, everyone work in perfect harmony for
the greater
>good-with occasional interaction with entirely incomprehensibly
individuated outsiders.
>How much fun is it role-playing super-ego, as compared to ego, or
especially and obviously, to id...

Either that or it devolves into a Greenpeace campaign.

Seriously, you point out exactly the problem I've been trying to overcome. So far, I've postulated that:
1. Aldryami Unity in the Song is rather like the Unity described in the Julian May books; i.e. it is not so all-encompassing that elves are incapable of individual initiative. They may be plants, but they are not vegetables.
2. Young elves are not even that Unified. Until they grow sex organs, they can't hear the song. These are the ones that often leave the forest. Rebellious youth and reconciliation to society are obvious themes here. 3. Different forests have markedly different traditions. So much so that that may seem as foreign as humans in some cases. We know that there have been inter-elven wars. What the heck were these about? Have these issues really been resolved, or do they fester under the surface? I've always thought that the proximity of Eronwood and Ballid, which are identified as separate forests, must make for occasional warfare between them.
4. I suspect that there may be different ways, within a single forest, to interpret and add to the Song. (Is it heavy metal or rap?) Mike Dawson's thoughts on speciation are a good materialistic basis for differences in the "tome" of the Song between parts of the Forest. 5. An RQ elf-campaign would be dull. (Even more so if you prefer the gritty clan-based style of play. "Ho hum, another day of tending my trees.") An HW campaign might not be. After all HW is about changing the face of the world. What better followers could a hero have than a nearly mindless bunch of hyped up war trees? (For the military strategists, all that thinking about the need for supply lines goes right out the window. They just put down roots until morning.) 6. Most conflicts will be with the humans. A number of Aldryami forests have extensive interactions with humans. Many hay actually have hsunchen living in them, more or less at Aldryami sufferance. The Umathelan and Erriroru Jungle elves have varying degrees of dominance over and conflict with humans. The Winterwood will grow all the way to Rathorela overnight at some point; what happen to the reindeer hsunchen living there now?

Chris Lemens

End of The Glorantha Digest V7 #819

Powered by hypermail