FWIW, the bucklers we use in C15 combat are affectionately refered to as "saucepan lids". In fact they curve the other way, with the handle on the inside, not the outside, but the size is about the same though the steel is heavier.
You *might* stop a full-strength blow with a broadsword (we pull all ours of course), but I think you'd hurt your wrist doing it.
There's some great "bucklers" in museums that are almost arm-armour - strapped onto the wrist, and covered in what I can only describe as chaos spikey bits. Definitely a weapon as well as a defence.
Powered by hypermail