The chart shows the word "Player," not the word "Instigator" - so it could be interpreted to allow the PCs to have the advantage in the case of tied levels of success, maybe as a form of narrative privilege.
...
> Like David, I don't think this would work for most groups. Though,
> evidently, it does work for some, which is useful to know.
Unless allowing the PCs the narrative privilege supposed above, I prefer using "high roll wins in case of tied level of success" - because "high roll" wins actually gives advantage to the higher adjusted rating. (I'd also not allow a mere Tie for mutual fumbles, but that's a minor detail.)
Powered by hypermail