Seems to me that there are two things that are missing from this discussion. Isn't Gark the Calm the god of Zombies? Gark is listed as a chaos god, which would suggest that Zombies are linked to the Chaos rune. Zorak Zoran, if this is true, borrows from this power, so we have a contradiction here.
Secondly, Darkness is not associated with Zombies, or rather, skeletons and zombies are not necessarily associated with the darkness rune. Ghosts, wraiths and other discorporate spirits are (through subere), and these are also "undead", but animated corpses are not, since there are no other troll gods that seem to practice zombie making. ZZ is unique in this regard, but then again, he is unique in many ways, he is not even really a troll god originally, he is a "adopted" god like Elmal was adopted from the sun tribe and Issaries was adopted from the Sea tribe into the Storm tribe.
I think ZZ powers have more to do with his origins as a god that came to hell from the outside. Denying hell of a spirit by fixing it to a corpse seems to me like a thing that a true god of hell wouldnt do.
Basically I think ZZs practice of corpse animation is unnatural even to trolls. After all they eat their dead in funeral rights, a zombie robs from both the community and the god of hell.
I think undead making becomes chaotic when it involves the annihilation of something in the world, any magic that permanently robs the world of energy is chaotic, thus Vampires are inherently chaotic, thanatary heads, chrimson bat, etc...
I also think there are two kinds of zombie/skeleton magic: One type involves enslaving the soul to the corpse (Gark), and this is chaotic since the soul is denied transit to its god's afterlife, the other type is purely the animation of a corpse with magical power (Sorcery, ZZ). Animating a skeleton does not enslave a soul, the soul is long gone to its god realm and your magic doesnt bring it back into the mundane world to power a set of bones.
Basically I think there are 2 kinds of zombies, the chaotic type that Gark makes, and which Delecti is a master practitioner of, and then there is the inanimate object zombie, purely a magically powered construct that doesnt actually contain a soul, just a permanent piece of the creator's soul. This is the ZZ zombie.
Powered by hypermail