Re: Berkleyism

From: Bibishar_at_aol.com
Date: Wed, 3 Jul 1996 22:27:07 -0400


Sandy opines:

> The Storm King can be perceived differently by different
> folks, just as my wife, my daughter, my son, my boss, my co-worker
> perceive me differently. But there is still only one me.

How do we _know_ there is "only one you"? Worse yet, what do you mean by "only one you"? You the ID software person? You the father? You the Gloranthan guru?

I know this may sound silly, but consider the case of a college friend of mine. After she had suffered through a bout of mononucleosis, her personality appeared to change radically. She abandoned _all_ her old friends and found others (with completely different interests). For me, she had become a "different" person, even though the body appeared the same. You might say she is the "same" person, but I include her pre-mono personality in her personhood.

Let's face it - people who don't like relativity in this world also tend not to like it in Glorantha. (Conversely, those who do, do.) I'm not sure it's a good subject for actually convincing others of one's beliefs, although it is fine for a good, old-fashioned argument. (grin)

If you want the argument, then begin by explaining to me how relativistic dieties in Glorantha "have harmed (IMO) Glorantha" _without_ falling back on your own prejudices.
(opinions, beliefs, etc.) I'm not convinced it can be done, since taking beliefs (opinions, etc.) away from the argument appears (to me) to expose the lack of "One True/Universal Standard" for measuring such things.

james polk


Powered by hypermail