Re: Gloranthan products

From: Sergio Mascarenhas <sermasalmeida_at_mail.telepac.pt>
Date: Tue, 31 Mar 1998 13:13:00 +0100


Shannon Appel:
> If you're photocopying them you're violating the author's
> intellectual property.

Legaly yes, but econommicaly no. The authors are not loosing any bucks since they have nothing to sell right now. In fact, it's the auction system that's deterimental to their economical interests. In this system, it's the intermediary that's making all the money, not the authors.

> By doing so you're also making it less likely that Chaosium/Issaries
> will ever be able to reprint the background material that appeared in
> those books.

I suspect it's just the opposite. I buyed the Pavis box in 83 and was stupid enough to let it go in my careless youth days. I would have buyed RoC (which I did) even if I still had the Pavis box. And most people that want to play in the Pavis and Rubble area, want to know that what they are developing is consistent with it. So, if they have a copy, they know it is. When the background material comes out they will most likely buy it. After all, they are already investing on it, and they're wayting for it. What they may not buy is something about Pamaltela: they are not playing in Pamaltela, they are playing in Prax, and don't want to change.

> I put together my entire RQ2 collection between about 1990
> and 1995 [skip] I paid as little as $2 for some books, as much as
> $100 for a few.

Let me tell you what I would ratter do: make a copy of that old material, and save the $100 to buy the "real" thing when it comes out from Issaries Inc. by $20, instead of giving away $80 to an intermediary. I mean, those extra $80 are not going to be used to finance what I want: new Glorantha materials. (Not that I'm doing this BTW.)

> I can tell you briefly that Issaries doesn't plan to revisit old
> locales in the first few years of publication (instead you'll get to
> travel to Orlanthi countries, the Lunar Empire, the homes of the Elder
> Races, the hero plane, and the oceans), so if you take the time to
> search out those RQ2 products, it'll be worth it for a few years at
> least. (And I trust that most people will be very happy to see totally
> new locales detailed, rather than just revisiting Dorastor and Prax.)
Now, I will tell you what I think will happen: if Issaries Inc. is successful (I realy hope so) and attracts a lot of new people to Glorantha, these people will acknowledge the existance of those mythical old boxes of RQ2 and RQ3 materials. The auction prices will rocket and the photocopies will continue to be very andy. Who is going to loose on this case? Issaries Inc., of course. Who is gaining? The people that owns the old stuff.

Now, let me ask a couple of questions?
1. How can it be that someone that owns an RQ2 book (I'm talking based on my own experience) and uses it intensely is able to keep it well preserved? I see only a possibility: phot...
2. Suppose someone owns Pavis and wants to make $100, BUT doesn't want to loose the content. What do you think such a person would do before selling the box? Phot... I realy think that the reason why people sell old Glorantha materials is BECAUSE of the existance of the photocopy machine. (I'm just gessing, I don't know of any real example to proove it.)

What should Chaosium do? IMHO Chaosium should make its policy to allow the photocopy of RQ2 materials FOR PERSONAL USE ONLY until Issaries Inc. starts publishing new materials (RQ3 books are another mather because they involve AH). No cost for Chaosium. No need to make new editions of the old materials. And making momentum to edit new materials based on the old settings.

Sergio


Powered by hypermail