A very good point. I'd add that in Glorantha, it may five components, there is always the practical magical component as well.
The basic point, that all cults have a mystic component, is a very important one. I'm pleased to see it reflected in the HW rules.
>BUT ; for a cult to be 'mystic', the mysticism of the religion must be
>dominant. And this doesn't work with the LotW as far as I can see.
Yes. There is a mystic secret here, but not a mystic life. The basic mystic path is about union with the divine, the absolute, and a rejection of worldly life. THe LotW path is different - its about interacting deeply with the world, or at least specific parts of it, even though it rejects normal human life.
>I could go on at great length, but I basically think that the LotW
>is a shamanic goddess. Certainly, she might have a stronger mystic
>component than most ; moreso than Odayla *certainly*.
I agree.
>But I also think that the way to go would be to develop her as an exotic
>shamanic tradition. Her devotees awaken no fetches, don't travel in
>the Spirit Plane (at least, not explicitely), and don't confront a
>'Bad Man' during their initiation rituals.
Yes, animal allies. They don't travel on the spirit plane, they 'vision quest' - alter their perceptions so that they can see and interact with the near spirit plane. And I think their initiation is confronting the lady herself in some way - they are casting off their old human civilised self, and becoming one of the ladies wild creatures.
Cheers David ------------------------------
Powered by hypermail