On Fri, 2005-29-07 at 07:05 +0100, Jane Williams wrote:
> I'd allow it. In-game, it makes good sense.
>
> In meta-gaming terms, it means that any initiate can have any feat, as long
> as the player can think on their feet and explain in the real-world minute
> before they use it who this Devotee is who created it, and how they know
> them. Which, again in meta-gaming terms, removes most of the advantages of
> being a Devotee.
>
> I don't see an easy solution to this, other than having reasonable players
> who don't try that sort of thing.
I don't see an easy answer, either. One is to make the Initiate PC
decide on a list when she first takes an Affinty. That seems a bit mean.
The other is to allow a substitution of a new Feat, but at the price of
no access to one currently on the list.
Neither seems ideal.
LC