Re: R: Re: Off topic romans

From: Jane Williams <janewilliams20_at_...>
Date: Fri, 13 Mar 2009 15:05:57 +0000 (GMT)

> > > *Probably* in the fifteen or so years between Borderlands and Imperial Lunar Handbook 1
> > > many enthusiastic fans put more 'roman' flavour in the scarce information that was provided for the Lunars

>> Make that "people" rather than the derisory "fans" and I'll agree with you.

> Really? To me fan is not derisory or derogatory, but... I consider myself a proud gloranthan fan.

But you quote what the original authors may have intended as if it mattered more than what *you* intended. As if you, as a "fan", are somehow less important to the development of Glorantha, all those people who developed the place in that 15-year span are less important, by being labelled "fan".

> To me, considering the roman as an evil empire is strange indeed and Asterix is mildly antipathic ;-)

Well, yes, I suppose so... I don't actually see the Romans as all that evil (small "e") myself, either. But the dramatic conflict is between Evil Empire and Heroic Barbarian: from that viewpoint, all empires are Evil simply by being empires, and that definitely includes the British one.       

Powered by hypermail