Accents (was [HeroQuest-RPG] Re: literacy)

From: Nick Brooke <Nick_at_...>
Date: Thu, 23 Sep 2004 19:05:32 -0000


Jeff wrote:

> FWIW, I don't think Heortlander *sounds* anything like English.

Nor do I.

Over on the other list, I was only suggesting that regional accents (e.g. Yorkshire vs. Mummerset) were IMO a more fruitful analogy for the differences between the Theyalan "languages" (e.g. Tarshite vs. Sartarite) than (say) distinctly different languages from the same family (e.g. Spanish vs. French; more extremely, English vs. German).

*Especially* given HeroQuest's narrative drive to downplay linguistic difficulties.

(Note too that I was talking about accents rather than dialects).

> (Nick - any ideas?).

None whatsoever. That's not my specialism.

> As a West Coast American, none of those accents do it for me.
> Yorkshire, Lancashire or other Northern English dialects mean
> very little to me, other than they are pretty much unintelligible
> and inexplicable.

Yeah, you'd need your own local equivalents (if you were going to do anything serious with this), and I can't help with those.

This is partly about emotive associations, after all. "Trollpak" (1st ed.) had a brief discussion of accents GMs could use for Uz NPCs -- Chicago Gangsters or Germans were suggested, IIRC (in the "Into Uzdom" book). Don't read too much into it.

Cheers, Nick

PS: complete agreement re: the Volsaxi droopy moustaches!

Powered by hypermail